Will-writers a bit worse than solicitors as charities highlight shoddy wills

Will-writing: unanimous support among charities for regulation

Half of charities have experienced a poorly drafted will from a will-writer, a new survey has revealed – but a third have also seen shoddy work from a solicitor.

A survey of over 50 charities by Remember A Charity found unanimous support for regulation of the will-writing sector, as a third had experienced “negative impacts of the sector not being regulated” – such as a loss of income – while poorly drafted wills had given 53% of them problems.

As a result, 52% of charities had had to engage solicitors to sort out the problem, while the time to get the money was significantly increased in 48% of cases. The charity received a smaller than expected legacy in a third of cases and lost the legacy entirely in 11% of cases.

Remember A Charity is part of the Institute of Fundraising, with a separate membership of over 140 charities, including nine of the top 10 charities by voluntary income. The survey was conducted as part of Remember A Charity’s response to the Legal Services Consumer Panel’s call for evidence as it investigates the need for regulation of the sector.

There was a range of opinions among charities on what form regulation should take, but the response said: “Overall it was felt that it should be light touch to minimise additional cost for the sector that would be passed onto consumers.” Increasing the cost of wills and so discouraging people from making them was the only real concern around introducing regulation.

It was also felt that there should be “a grievance procedure for people to turn to when things were going wrong”. There was some support for the current Institute of Professional Willwriters’ regulations, at least as a starting point.

The charities listed others issues that any regulation should address, including:

  • Providing consumers with similar protection to that of work done by solicitors;
  • Considering maximum pricing for any executorship;
  • Considering mandatory continuing professional development; and
  • All will-writers having indemnity insurance at a similar level to solicitors.

“Only by regulation will consumers feel more confident in the will provider that they use and will be sufficiently protected for when things go wrong,” the response concluded. “This can only improve the situation for the beneficiaries they leave behind at what is understandably a difficult time.”

Legal Futures reported last week that the Legal Services Board will on whether to regulate will-writing until well into 2012.


    Readers Comments

  • Rod Fisher says:

    The findings of this survey are hardly a surprise.

    Perhaps solicitors will now be less forceful in projecting a ‘holier than thou’ attitutude towards professional Willwriters!

    It’s clear that both solicitors and professional Will writers need to improve their standards and put their respective houses in order.

  • Ken Curtis says:

    This is one of the most important documents that you will ever have drawn up in your lifetime, it is well worth the money to seek professional advice and get it done right whether through a solicitor or will-writer.
    The problem is that people take will instructions who are neither qualified nor regulated and they use case systems that pre-generate generic documents that are not checked.
    Problems don’t come to light until post death and often by then the company having drafted the will is no longer in existence and there is no one to sue to compensate the beneficiary who is harmed.

Leave a Comment

By clicking Submit you consent to Legal Futures storing your personal data and confirm you have read our Privacy Policy and section 5 of our Terms & Conditions which deals with user-generated content. All comments will be moderated before posting.

Required fields are marked *
Email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Loading animation