Will-writing body set for rule change after report questions value of pre-paid probate plans

Print This Post

30 January 2014


Will-writing: representative body says PPPs offer no advantages

The Society of Will Writers (SWW) is set to adopt a code of conduct change that will prevent its members from taking advance payments for acting in the administration of a client’s estate.

The move followed publication of SWW research on the apparent rise of firms offering pre-paid probate plans (PPP), which advised consumers to be sceptical about claims made by PPP providers.

The report by James Greenwood, case administrator with the SWW Trust Corporation, stopped short of stating that all PPPs were worthless, but queried the supposed advantages of taking them out. “The case for PPP seems to have failed,” he said.

Advance plans are sold on the basis that reviewing consumers’ assets periodically saves fact-finding time, thereby reducing distress to friends and relatives in the post-death period, and can make estates less vulnerable to inheritance tax.

Mr Greenwood found these benefits were at best only true to “a certain extent” and while delivering “few clear advantages”, required “an element of risk”.

He concluded: “Those benefits of PPP which withstand scrutiny are largely transferable to a traditional probate service model, provided a fact-finding service before death can be arranged…

“It is better, it seems, to rely on the services of a trustworthy traditional probate service provider, than try to oversimplify with a PPP plan and sign on the dotted line, ignoring the quiet menace of the small print.”

Earlier this month, the Society of Trust and Estate Practitioners introduced a that included the statement: “No will drafter shall prepare a will and require, solicit or otherwise attempt to obtain any advance payment for acting in the administration of the client’s estate.”

The SWW said: “[The SWW] board will recommend to the executive council that our code should be reviewed to include a similar requirement on members.”

But it admitted: “There is little information available at present regarding the quantity of such plans being sold, or whether these plans have been received with any widespread criticism.”

In a response to the on will-writing, probate and estate administration services in 2012, the probate company ITC – which claims to be the UK’s largest probate provider – said it “regularly” encountered PPP, among other areas of “mis-selling and fraud”, adding: “Pre-paid probate is, in our opinion, the largest dormant but inevitable disaster that will hit this whole sector. For many decades (over 50 years), wills have been written as a loss leader to lock beneficiaries into using the firm, company or individual as executor.”

Tags: , ,



One Response to “Will-writing body set for rule change after report questions value of pre-paid probate plans”

  1. The main issue here is the long term solvency of the organisation to whom the advance payment is made. In the current economic climate there is no guarantee that the organisation will be around to deliver the service 5 ; 10 or 15 years from now. The SWW report seems to have missed this central public interest point.

  2. Jayne Willetts on February 3rd, 2014 at 8:00 am

Leave a comment

* Denotes required field

All comments will be moderated before posting. Please see our Terms and Conditions

Legal Futures Blog

How to make a case to the unconverted

Jonathan Whittle

The prospect of change is a daunting one, whether you’re a global firm or a small one. You might think that your firm’s working practices are fine, or that there’s no value in altering the way you do things because of the disruption it would cause. You might even see the benefits of using a different methodology, but still refuse to put the effort in to implement it – and you wouldn’t be alone. From our research in the 2016 report, The Riddle of Perception, we know that 73% of lawyers believe that adapting to change is not where their strength lies. However, it’s no longer optional.

November 16th, 2017