SRA moves to take unlimited fining power for economic crime


Fines: The sky’s the limit 

The Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) has finally sought permission to activate its power to issue unlimited fines in cases involving economic crime.

It said that implementing the power granted in the Economic Crime and Corporate Transparency Act 2023 (ECCTA), which came into force on 4 March 2024, would allow it to deal with such cases much more quickly as they would no longer need to be referred to the Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal (SDT).

The SRA has first to revise the guidance on its approach to fines and have this approved by the Legal Services Board (LSB).

The application went in recently and the SRA suggested that it did not need to go through the approval process that usually applies to significant rule changes. It is not clear whether the LSB has agreed to this.

ECCTA removes the cap on financial penalties – currently £25,000 – that can be imposed on solicitors, traditional law firms and their employees for rule breaches and misconduct falling within its definition of economic crime, where the conduct started on or after 4 March 2024.

The definition includes theft, fraud, false accounting, bribery, tax evasion, money laundering, terrorist financing, and breaches of financial sanctions.

The application highlighted three cases referred to the SDT last year for breaches of anti-money laundering requirements.

“Each case was settled by way of an agreed outcome approved by the tribunal, ranging from £58,000 to £300,000, plus costs. With the removal of the SRA’s cap on fines for breaches of economic crime, these three cases would have been resolved more quickly, and without associated costs.”

Though the SRA guidance provides that a fine would usually be no more than 5% of a firm’s turnover, this “cannot… fetter the discretion of our authorised decision makers”, the application said.

“There may be exceptional cases where an authorised decision maker departs from the guidance, for example by imposing a fine that is higher than 5% of annual domestic turnover, or using a different metric to determine an appropriate fine.”

The application said the new power would apply to those regulated by another legal regulator, such as a barrister or chartered legal executive, where employed by an SRA-regulated firm.

It has talked to both the Bar Standards Board and CILEx Regulation and, in the event either was conducting their own probe, the SRA’s existing guidance on how it approaches parallel investigations would apply.

ECCTA made changes to the Solicitors Act 1974. Alternative business structures and those working in them are subject to a different regime, under the Legal Services Act 2007, and the SRA can already fine them up to £250m and £50m respectively. They are not affected by this.

In 2024, the SRA consulted on revised fining guidance that went much further than the ECCTA changes but received a strong backlash from the profession.

This was put on the backburner as a result but the SRA has been slowly progressing the ECCTA changes and carried out a limited consultation on the guidance with the national Law Society and local law societies.

The application added that the SRA was separately conducting an internal review to establish whether other changes to its fining framework still needed making.




    Readers Comments

  • A Joseph says:

    This is concerning not least because they struggle to use the powers they already have appropriately and/or to make effective decisions.

  • Annie Joseph says:

    Notice how this follows an article that 1 in 5 of the cases they take to the SDT fail.

    It would be funny, were it not so transparent and depressing.


Leave a Comment

By clicking Submit you consent to Legal Futures storing your personal data and confirm you have read our Privacy Policy and section 5 of our Terms & Conditions which deals with user-generated content. All comments will be moderated before posting.

Required fields are marked *
Email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Blog


Dr Gleb Tsipursky

The AI competence test every junior solicitor should pass

A junior solicitor can produce a polished legal argument with an AI tool before lunch. The more revealing question comes afterward: can that solicitor explain it?


The AI question law firms should answer before a client asks it

Most law firms we speak to are already using AI, whether or not they have approved it, because fee-earners are doing it anyway. The tool people settle on is often Claude.


From chat to Cowork: preparing your law firm for agentic AI

AI is evolving quickly. For law firms still working out how to get consistent value from the tools they already have, the conversation has moved on again to agentic AI.


Loading animation