New Bar chief keeps up anti-LSB rhetoric

McGowan: direct access forms an increasing source of work

The new Bar Council chairman has pledged to work towards proving that the Legal Services Board (LSB) is not needed.

In a stinging attack on the LSB – continuing a Bar Council campaign of recent months – Maura McGowan QC warned that “it is not the function of a regulator to seek the total dismantling and restructuring of the system”.

In her inaugural address to the Bar Council earlier this week, Ms McGowan said: “Recently I was asked to suggest names of members of the Bar who might become members of the Legal Services Board, the request was couched in terms that I nominate barristers ‘committed’ to change in the provision of legal services. My reply, that surely what they wanted was people ‘open’ to change, was met with stunned and continuing silence.

“The LSB is with us for at least the next two years. Its second term was granted after its first review. There is support both in government and in general for the view that regulation should not be too heavy a burden. As a profession which was recognised for the efficacy of its self-regulation, surely we can work towards meeting the next review by being able to demonstrate that one external regulator is enough.”

In a speech that was notable for not referencing either alternative business structures or the Quality Assurance Scheme for Advocates – especially as she is a criminal law practitioner – Ms McGowan highlighted the role of direct access in opening up the Bar to foreign lawyers.

“[Direct access] forms an increasing source of work to certain areas of practice; it is thriving but must be further encouraged. Almost half the self-employed Bar has trained and is now qualified to accept instructions in this way. That cannot simply be as a result of the difficulties which the publicly funded Bar faces, it must mean that there is a need on the part of clients, domestic and international, to instruct counsel by this route.

“Further there is a willingness, possibly even enthusiasm, on the part of barristers to receive work in this way. It is a supplementary format; it is not designed nor should it replace the traditional provision and acceptance of instructions.”

Ms McGowan said that for direct access to be effective in producing work for the publicly funded Bar, the Bar Standards Board needs to change the rules to allow a barrister to accept direct instructions in cases where the client is eligible for legal aid. She also called on barristers to join in a new project to design a new model for legal aid.

“It may well have many aspects of the old, it may be completely new, we must see and seize an opportunity for changing the system for the better,” she said.



    Readers Comments

  • I would have thought the Bar Council had more important things to worry about, like increased competition and cuts in publicly funded work threatening the livelihood of some of its members. Obviously not.

  • This is a very fair point made by Ms McGowan QC?Why do we need the LSB? What does it do? How much does it cost? More regulation and red tape which Cameron is supposed to be committed to removing? The general consensus amongst the PI profession is that our esteemed PM has a grudge against solicitors and is determined to drive us all out of business, which means loss of VAT, PAYE, TAX whilst insurers are busy toadying up to him and siphoning off the profits offshore. These MoJ reforms will batter part of middle income taxpayers and will be very influential in voting trends at the next election. We are educated Mr Cameron and remember who has driven forth these reforms resulting in a denial of access to justice, significant further redundancies, and loss of revenue to HMRC. Please do not even think that insurance premiums will decrease pro rata to the savings made by insurers on not paying damages and costs. The government will pay for their behaviour at the next election.

Leave a Comment

By clicking Submit you consent to Legal Futures storing your personal data and confirm you have read our Privacy Policy and section 5 of our Terms & Conditions which deals with user-generated content. All comments will be moderated before posting.

Required fields are marked *
Email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


How can law firms adapt to post-pandemic working?

As law firms emerge from the pandemic, they face the challenges of coping with its aftermath while settling on new ways of working in the long-term.

The hot graphic design trends in the legal sector

As we recover from an unprecedented 19 months within our sector, marketing teams and clerks’ rooms are keener than ever to try out something new in the promotion of their businesses.

What challenges will the Bar face in the next five years?

As we look towards the end of 2021 and at how the Bar has adapted to the harsh realities of the pandemic, the question beckons as to what the future holds.

Loading animation