
Atkinson: Early help needed
MPs have put a national legal service to co-ordinate the advice network and legal regulation reform at the heart of recommendations to improve access to legal services.
The justice select committee also supported an Interest of Lawyers Clients Accounts (ILCA) scheme in principle but not as proposed by the Ministry of Justice (MoJ), as well as directing dormant client account balances to access to justice charities.
The access to legal services report is the latest and weightiest output from its access to justice inquiry and puts the onus on government to take a “more active, strategic and accountable role”.
It said: “Access to justice must be treated as a core purpose of the Ministry of Justice, not as a collection of disconnected programmes. Legal rights are meaningful only where people can recognise them, obtain reliable assistance and secure an effective remedy.”
It described the legal advice sector as “sustained by a patchwork of legal aid, local authority commissioning, charitable grants, pro bono work and short-term government programmes”.
This insecurity made it difficult to retain experienced staff, develop specialist expertise or invest in services – and contributed to a postcode lottery “in which the assistance available depends on where a person lives and how their problem is categorised”.
The headline recommendation is for the creation of a national legal service “which treats reducing unmet legal need as a cross-government responsibility and establishes a permanent programme of work with sufficient authority, expertise and resources to coordinate delivery”.
Its aims would be to provide people with reliable legal information and identify which support is appropriate for them, analogous to NHS 111, signpost between different services while measuring their demand and capacity, and identify shortfalls in provision and directing resources to addressing them.
Like the NHS, the national legal service “should combine a clear national identity and set of expectations with services delivered locally through different organisations”.
Lord Chancellor Alex Norris referenced his ambition for a national legal service at last weekend’s Bar Council conference.
The report said the MoJ should invest in digital and AI-assisted services “which can expand access to affordable legal support”, including unbundled legal services and, longer term, an AI-assisted legal support platform that provides a single point of entry to help people identify whether their problem has a legal dimension, understand their options, and navigate to appropriate information, advice or representation.
There should also be a public legal information repository to reduce the risk of AI hallucinations, as well as a plan for the use of AI to reduce administrative burdens on legal aid providers, including an online eligibility checker.
The committee said the MoJ should raise additional revenue through a “portfolio” of funding mechanisms and strictly ring-fence it for reducing unmet legal need. “Supplementary income cannot compensate for an inadequate core settlement for legal aid, courts or other justice services,” it stressed.
An ILCA scheme could provide substantial additional funding, but its benefits depended on its design. “That some firms operate on tight margins does not preclude the fact that there are many healthy firms who, evidence indicates, are profiting significantly from client interest,” it said.
The committee did not like the MoJ’s proposed scheme, which would see interest simply funnelled into its general budget.
Rather, as in other jurisdictions, it should be administered independently of government and operate on the basis of transparent grant-making criteria focused on reducing unmet legal need.
It should maintain reserves to manage volatility, and include safeguards such as appropriate exemptions for legal aid providers and other financially vulnerable firms.
Residual client balances “could provide a modest supplementary source of funding for access to justice”, with a common independent recipient offering greater consistency than the present firm-by-firm approach.
The report also highlighted undistributed collective action sums and “carefully targeted contributions” from litigation funding profits and high-value litigation.
We have reported separately on the recommendations about legal regulation reform.
Other key recommendations include:
- Expanding on the MoJ’s existing work on health-justice partnerships;
- Working with insurers, regulators and consumer organisations to improve the visibility and availability of before-the-event legal expenses insurance;
- Extending levy support to the sector for Level 7 apprenticeships for those over 21 years of age;
- Increasing investment in public legal education;
- Assessing the categories of claim where conditional fee agreements remain economically viable, and whether they continue to provide an effective route to justice, and how the rules governing costs and recoverability affect the willingness of practitioners to take on meritorious cases;
- Extending qualified one-way costs shifting (QOCS) to include discrimination and abuse claims, and consider whether it should extend to non-medical professional negligence and judicial review claims too;
- Reviewing the operation, “and concerns about weaponisation”, of the fundamental dishonesty rules within QOCS, including whether the present framework provides “appropriate and equivalent safeguards against unreasonable conduct by defendants”;
- Reviewing the level and scope of fixed recoverable costs should determine whether they adequately reflect the actual cost of conducting litigation, establish a mechanism for their regular review and uprating, and provide clarity about their application to housing claims;
- Backing the Civil Justice Council’s report last year calling for legislation to reverse the effects of the PACCAR judgment, saying it should have retrospective effect, and also introduce a “proportionate statutory regulatory regime for third-party litigation funding; and
- Allowing the Financial Conduct Authority to regulate portfolio funding arrangements as a form of lending.
Committee chair Catherine Atkinson, a Labour MP, said: “Demand for legal help is rising, yet advice services are shrinking and where you live can determine what help you can get. We recognise the value of getting help early in the NHS.
“The same principle applies to justice. Early legal advice can help people resolve problems before they reach a court or tribunal, saving them time, money and stress…
“For too long, legal advice has been provided through a disjointed system, with responsibility spread across government departments, councils, charities and regulators. The Ministry of Justice should take the lead in coordinating services, checking whether they can meet demand and acting where people are going without help.
“Legal rights are meaningful only where people can recognise them, obtain reliable assistance and secure an effective remedy. The MoJ must treat access to justice as a core purpose, not as a collection of disconnected programmes.”













Leave a Comment