Legal regulators face having to appoint ‘small business appeals champions’


Chris Kenny

Kenny: only front-line regulators have the power to take action

The Legal Services Board (LSB) has told the government that if it wants to appoint ‘small business appeals champions’ for legal services, it should appoint them to the eight front-line regulators rather than the super-regulator.

Responding to a Department for Business, Innovation and Skills (BIS) consultation, LSB chief executive Chris Kenny said the board did “not consider that the government’s policy aims will be achieved if the requirement for a champion is applied to the LSB”.

In his foreword to the consultation paper, Michael Fallon, minister of state for business, said that poor decisions by regulators were left to stand “because businesses do not know how to challenge them or because challenging them is simply too expensive or time-consuming”.

Mr Fallon said small business appeals champions – senior part-time appointees – would scrutinise the way appeals and complaints were handled by regulators and make recommendations for improvements.

Departments and regulators would be expected to consider any recommendations and either implement them or explain publicly why they had decided not to do so. The champions would have no role in intervening in individual cases, nor any power to do so.

Mr Kenny agreed with “the desirability of addressing shortcomings in regulators’ appeal mechanisms” but argued that only front-line regulators, such as the Solicitors Regulation Authority or Bar Standards Board, had the power to take enforcement action.

“The LSB cannot take action against individual lawyers or businesses,” he said. “Therefore we do not consider that the government’s policy aims will be achieved if the requirement for a champion is applied to the LSB.

“For appeals champions to be effective in legal services, the obligation needs to include all the front-line regulators because their actions directly affect small businesses.”

Mr Kenny also took issue with the idea that the role of champion could be, as BIS put it in the consultation paper, “independent of their regulator” while they were also a non-executive director (NED) of it.

He said that one of the responsibilities of a NED was to be collectively responsible for decisions about the organisation.

“It seems unlikely that an individual NED would be able to exercise sufficient independence from that role to also carry out the functions of a champion,” Mr Kenny said.

“We therefore suggest that BIS may want to reconsider this issue to ensure that the champion is of sufficient seniority and able to carry out their role independently.”

Mr Kenny asked whether BIS had considered testing the whole business champion as a concept in a few regulators, which could help identify practical problems and highlight good practice.

He added that any obligation to provide a public explanation in the event of a disagreement with a small business champion should apply to BIS, as well as the regulator.

 

Tags:




    Readers Comments

  • Joe Reevy says:

    I think I agree with this. Interestingly, have been in conversations recently with a newly-formed consultancy and the ICAEW which bear on this indirectly.

    I think I sense the seed of a new sort of consensus developing about how small business legal services should be delivered: outside the profession, in any event.


Leave a Comment

By clicking Submit you consent to Legal Futures storing your personal data and confirm you have read our Privacy Policy and section 5 of our Terms & Conditions which deals with user-generated content. All comments will be moderated before posting.

Required fields are marked *
Email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Blog


The hot graphic design trends in the legal sector

As we recover from an unprecedented 19 months within our sector, marketing teams and clerks’ rooms are keener than ever to try out something new in the promotion of their businesses.


What challenges will the Bar face in the next five years?

As we look towards the end of 2021 and at how the Bar has adapted to the harsh realities of the pandemic, the question beckons as to what the future holds.


The rise of cyber-criminal threat for law firms since Covid-19

The global coronavirus pandemic, and the rise in people working from home, has unfortunately provoked a growth in cyber-crime. The UK government estimates that the cost of cyber-crime is £27bn per annum.


Loading animation