
Kachel: Judgement is the differentiator
Law firms must demonstrate that the efficiencies they are achieving through AI are being passed on to clients or risk losing work, leading general counsel have warned.
A trio of senior in-house lawyers said they were increasingly challenging firms over their pricing, questioning traditional staffing models and demanding greater evidence of the value they deliver.
Speaking at Chambers Connects in London – an event held to launch the Chambers Advantage Index UK – James Kachel, general counsel of Compass Group, said it had completed multiple acquisitions worldwide in recent years but had not seen its legal spend on them fall far enough despite its panel law firms investing heavily in AI.
“The firms that will come up on top of that are those that can drive those efficiencies and share the benefit with their clients,” he said.
Fiona Day, deputy general counsel at Lloyds Banking Group, said the bank was already asking for more information about the savings firms were making.
“We are adapting how we are working, and we don’t just ask for price. We ask, are you using AI and please be transparent around the pricing and savings for that. And we will continue to request that transparency.”
She predicted that pricing could evolve further in the future and could move away from time spent towards models based on risk or outcomes.
She questioned the traditional law firm pyramid and how clients could continue to justify paying £500 an hour for junior lawyers to undertake work that AI could complete at a fraction of the cost.
Pia Sarma, deputy general counsel of News UK and editorial legal director of Times Media, agreed that firms needed to reconsider how junior lawyers were deployed.
“I don’t want somebody attending a meeting, writing things and spending hours typing them up,” she said. “We don’t need that because we have tools that can do that for us.”
However, the panel acknowledged that removing routine work created a problem for the profession around how junior lawyers would develop the experience and judgement needed to become senior advisers.
Ms Sarma suggested that secondments could become increasingly important, allowing young lawyers to understand clients’ businesses rather than spend their early careers on routine tasks.
Ms Day predicted that law firms which were slow to embrace AI risked losing clients: “There will be really clear winners and losers and obviously we want to be collaborating with the winners.”
But the lawyers were equally clear that there would always be a market for premium specialist advice. “Excellence really is the entry ticket these days,” Mr Kachel said. “Judgement is the differentiator.”
His experience was that too many law firms claimed to understand their clients without knowing enough about their commercial objectives, internal pressures or appetite for risk.
He highlighted the limited value of generic legal updates sent to in-house lawyers. What he wanted was for firms to explain what a development meant for Compass and what the business should actually do about it.
On firms’ claims to be proactive, Mr Kachel added: “Everybody professes to do it. Very few law firms actually deliver, sadly.”
Other factors that could undermine client relationships included unexpected bills, sending too many lawyers to meetings and not coordinating advice between international offices. Mr Kachel also stressed the importance of keeping the GC in the loop and not bypassing them.
Ms Day said Lloyds had become more demanding about the information it required from panel firms, using data to assess performance and standardised pitch documents to compare pricing. Cybersecurity was now a major consideration in choosing advisers, alongside sustainability and diversity.
But personal relationships still counted. She said lawyers who made themselves available when clients were under pressure were particularly valued.
Ms Sarma agreed. News UK needed lawyers who could respond immediately when a publication faced a threatened injunction or another urgent legal problem. In those circumstances, the ability to mobilise quickly and exercise sound judgement justified premium fees.
She added that her team was actively developing internal tools to assist with routine legal work, freeing her team to tackle higher-value matters.













Leave a Comment