
MPs: Regulation not supporting access to justice
A new regulatory settlement is needed “because the present framework does not serve access to justice well and is not equipped to respond to a changing legal services market”, MPs say today.
The justice select committee agreed with the conclusion of the 2026 public bodies review of the Legal Services Board (LSB), namely that “the regulation of legal services requires fundamental review”.
The system could be made simpler through creating a single legal services regulator, the committee said.
This in turn could potentially “focus more effectively on the activities undertaken and risks posed to consumers, rather than principally on professional titles and organisational form”. This is the model proposed by Professor Stephen Mayson.
Regulatory reform was one of four core recommendations of the committee’s access to legal services report, the latest and weightiest output from its access to justice inquiry. We report on its other recommendations separately [1].
It said legal services regulation had not been an aim of the inquiry but, in the context of access to justice, there were at least three core problems with the current framework.
These were inadequate consumer protection, the use of technology by unregulated providers to deliver legal services, and how “an underpowered oversight regulator (the LSB) attempting to hold eight separate regulators to account, while overseeing the [Legal Ombudsman] and Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal, has not delivered on its regulatory objectives”.
The independent LSB review, conducted by Richard Lloyd, said in July [2] that the LSB has “lost its way” in recent years and a reset was needed while work began on a wider review of regulation.
Earlier this month, the Ministry of Justice (MoJ) accepted all of his recommendations [3] and said it would undertake a “comprehensive review” of whether legal services regulation remains fit for purpose.
The committee said: “Consumers cannot easily establish whether a provider is regulated, what protections regulation gives or where to seek redress.
“Recent firm failures have also exposed serious weaknesses in supervision and damaged consumer confidence.
“Poorly targeted regulation can also increase costs and inhibit low-cost, unbundled, not-for-profit and technology-enabled services. There must be greater emphasis on regulated activities and risks, clearer consumer information and redress, and effective oversight of new digital and AI-assisted services.”
One of the regulatory objectives in the Legal Services Act 2007 is to improve access to justice but the committee found that the Act “over-promises and under-delivers”.
There was “scant evidence” that this objective had encouraged regulators to take proactive steps towards it, even though it had “encouraged useful research and attention to innovation”.
“It appears that the LSB and frontline regulators are not equipped to tackle the major challenges facing access to justice in England and Wales.
“The idea behind the inclusion of the regulatory objectives in the 2007 Act was laudable. However, we have become convinced through our work on this topic that it is the government’s responsibility to improve access to justice.”
While regulation could affect price, innovation, confidence and service availability, the “principal levers” over public funding, public legal education, court administration and national service capacity remained with the government.
Indeed, the regulatory framework “does not serve access to justice well”.
“Consumers face inadequate and confusing information about providers, a fragmented and slow complaints system, and insufficient protection from firm failure.
“The repeated collapse of firms following missed warning signs demonstrates that legal services regulation fails to prevent serious consumer harm. These failings undermine confidence in legal services and reinforce the case for fundamental reform.”
Another outcome of the Lloyd review has been that the LSB is to focus more on core regulatory priorities.
The committee said this was right but it was concerned about the loss of system leadership on innovation and legal needs research that this will cause.
“These are gaps which the Legal Services Board has stepped into because of a lack of will and attention from government. This must be corrected.”
The report noted that, in 2024, its predecessor committee, then chaired by Sir Bob Neill, wrote in a letter to the Lord Chancellor [4] that “it is undeniable that the case for re-examination of the legislative framework underpinning regulation is growing stronger and stronger”.
It went on: “The evidence we have received in this inquiry further strengthens that conclusion.”