In-out, in-out: “there is capacity” say brokers after indemnity insurer hokey-cokey

Another underwriter believes solicitor risk is excessive

Professional indemnity insurance (PII) brokers have again had to calm fears just three weeks before the renewals deadline, as the unrated insurer Berliner appeared “uncertain” it could cover any solicitors’ risk this year.

Germany-based Berliner only entered the market this year, offering to insure firms of all sizes – and is said to have collected around £20m in premiums so far – and the news will come as a further shock to small firms in particular after rated insurer XL pulled out of the market for the smallest firms.

It is likely to drive some business to Chancery Pii, the Law Society’s joint venture with Miller Insurance Services, set up at the end of last month to offer direct, broker-free, access for small firms to three rated insurers.

In a letter to policyholders, drafted with the Financial Conduct Authority, Apro Management, an appointed representative of broker Bar Professions, said: “There is now uncertainty as to whether Berliner will… be in a position to accept any [PII] risks for the year beginning 1 October 2013.”

Premiums already received will be held in a client account “while we seek to resolve the situation” but the letter, signed by Apro directors Ray Watson and Wayne Redgrave, continued: “We consider however, there is some doubt as to whether replacement capacity can be secured in time… customers should consider making alternative arrangements for cover.”

It is understood that many of the 1,300 firms left uninsured when the Latvian insurer, Balva – also brokered by Bar Professions – was barred from the UK market, had their policies transferred to Berliner.

On 2 September, Apro wrote to policyholders saying it was no longer accepting new 2013/14 premiums for insurance underwritten by Berliner.

Colin Taylor, head of risk management at Prime Risk Solutions, part of global insurance broker Willis Group, said there was “now great interest” in its facilities providing cover with rated insurers Liberty, Axis and WR Berkley, among others.

“For any firms affected by this development, time is of the essence and solicitors need to ensure they provide a complete submission for consideration,” he said.

Simon Lovat of broker UIB added: “The potential for about 1,100 practices coming into the market to buy insurance 15 working days before renewal poses a significant challenge to brokers and insurers, who are already working at near capacity. For those firms that are still searching for qualifying insurance, there is the potential  that they will have to pay more than they expect to pay this year because of this late development.”

Stuart Dugdill, director of professional liabilities at Manchester-based broker MFL Professional, warned that firms without PII should “act fast but not panic” and should carefully assess any approaches from brokers to avoid those attempting to profit from the tight deadline.

“Firms need to take a view very quickly about getting involved with a broker. Telephone interviews can help to separate an opportunistic broker from one who is going to be able to get you into a couple of markets quickly.”

Mike Perry, a partner at broker JLT, said: “For any firms that are not sure of their position, the best thing you can do today is get another quote to be on the safe side.” He said JLT had “substantial capacity” with rated insurer AmTrust.


Leave a Comment

By clicking Submit you consent to Legal Futures storing your personal data and confirm you have read our Privacy Policy and section 5 of our Terms & Conditions which deals with user-generated content. All comments will be moderated before posting.

Required fields are marked *
Email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


A new route to practice rights for chartered legal executives

Following approval from the Legal Services Board in May 2022, CILEx Regulation has launched an alternative route for chartered legal executives to obtain independent practice rights.

NFTs, the courts and the role of injunctions

In May, news broke that a non-fungible token was the subject of a successful injunction made by the Singapore High Court. The NFT in question is part of the very valuable Bored Ape Yacht Club series.

Matthew Pascall

Low-value commercial cases – an achievable challenge for ATE insurers

There are many good claims brought for damages that are likely to be significantly less than twice the cost of bringing the claim. These cases present a real challenge for insurers.

Loading animation