Ex-FBI cyber chief warns lawyers over corporate espionage

Waisberg (right) and Wildisen: combining AI products can increase impact

Basic digital housekeeping like keeping software up-to-date and backing up data separately from your network will solve most cyber-security issues – with corporate espionage one issue law firms have to face – according to a former assistant director of the US Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI).

Speaking at Tuesday’s Legal Geek conference in London, John Boles, who directed the FBI’s global cyber operations and investigations during his 21-year career with the agency, said the cyber threat was real and “as bad as everybody says”.

He reported that during his time at the FBI, in the US alone there were over 6,000 active cases of cyber attack at any given time, ranging from ransomware and malware, to DDOS (denial of service). But these were “only the tip of the iceberg”, he said, because most attacks went unreported.

He said law firms were susceptible to attempted corporate espionage, especially if they were involved in “antagonistic cases”. He added: “It’s not uncommon for folks to be trying to find out what the other side’s thinking”.

But he said that much of the cyber-security battle could be won if firms “do the basics”. This included updating and regularly implementing software ‘patches’ provided by the vendor – aimed at removing security vulnerabilities.

Also, since ransomware attacks often targeted network-connected devices for encryption until a ransom was paid to unencrypt them, it was common sense to keep back-ups separate, he said. Firms should also keep passwords secure and ask themselves “does everyone in [the] company need to have access?”

Everyday software added to networks sometimes “shipped with security settings set to low or zero”, which needed customising on installation, he warned.

Mr Boles concluded: “The bad guys are out there and are thinking how can they monetise your data quicker than you can… Nobody loves your data like you love your data. It’s your crown jewels.”

Meanwhile, also at the conference, Noah Waisberg and Greg Wildisen, respectively the chief executive and international managing director of artificial intelligence (AI) software providers Kira Systems and Neota Logic, which are used by legal firms around the world to process documents and data, gave a joint presentation.

The pair described a phenomenon called ‘bricolage’, which is the use of more than one AI system in sequence to create a more powerful data refinement tool.

Mr Waisberg gave the example of a collaboration between three legal tech companies, Neota, Kira and data-sharing platform HighQ by Australian-based law firm, Allen. The three companies collaborated to create an AI application known as REDDA (Real Estate Due Diligence App) to analyse huge lease portfolios and flag areas for further review.

Mr Wildisen described bricolage as “taking tech

  • “Courting disaster” – Getting the rules on service rightComing soon

  • “Some Other Substantial Reason” for Dismissal: Catch-All or Last Resort?

  • A Lasting Legacy – Charities as Beneficiaries

  • A Review of Disabled and Vulnerable Beneficiary Trusts

  • A roundup of developments in SDLT

  • Adoption Law and Placement Orders 2021

  • Advances in Special Guardianship and Child Arrangements Orders

  • Adverse Possession: Is the law evolving?Coming soon

  • Agricultural Property Relief (APR) for Inheritance Tax (IHT)

  • Ambiguous Drafting in Property Contracts – Will the Courts Help and How?

  • An Introduction and Update to the Telecoms CodeComing soon

  • An Introduction to Residential Conveyancing for New Entrants

  • An Introduction to S106 Planning Obligations and Community Infrastructure Levy

  • An introduction to the probate process for paralegals and secretaries

  • Anti-Money Laundering Update September 2021

  • Boilerplate Clauses – Ignore Them At Your Peril

  • Bona vacantia, escheat and similar concepts – what you need to knowComing soon

  • Boundaries, Adverse Possession and Trespass

  • Business Asset Disposal Relief – a reviewComing soon

  • CGT for Executors

  • CGT on the disposal of UK residential property

  • Changing Renewal Lease Terms under the 1954 Act

  • Children and Family Law Update – Spring 2021

  • Children and Injunctions Advocacy

  • COFA – Your duties updated 2021

  • Collateral Warranties and Third Party Rights

  • COLP Update 2021

  • Commercial Agency Overview

  • Commercial Property Autumn Update

  • Commercial Property Spring Update

  • Commercial Property Spring Update 2021Coming soon

  • Commercial Property Summer Update 2021

  • Commercial Property Winter Update

  • Commercial Property Winter Update 2021

  • Commercial Rent (Coronavirus) Bill: The Impact on Commercial RentsComing soon

  • Compliance Update 2021

  • Compliance Update No 1. 2022Coming soon

  • Compliance: Transparency Rules, SQE and the SDLT holiday

  • Compulsory ADR – the new rules coming in 2022

  • Contentious Probate Round Up 2020

  • Contract Interpretation

  • Contract law – formation, exclusions and boilerplate

  • Corporate Law Update

  • Costs and Funding – latest developments in 2021

  • Cross Border Estates – A Refresher

  • Cybercrime and Fraud 2022Coming soon

  • Defamation – meaning, defences and remedies

  • Default and Sanctions 2021

  • Defaulting tenants: practical remedies

  • Development and restrictive covenants: tips and traps for developers and objectors

  • Discrimination – Direct and Indirect Victimisation, Harassment and Reasonable Adjustments

  • Divorce, Dissolution and Nullity Proceedings: Current Practice, Online Procedure and the Impact of the New Divorce, Dissolution and Separation ActComing soon

  • Domestic Abuse – Law and Practice for Family Practitioners

  • Drafting and Amending Alienation Clauses in Commercial Leases

  • Drafting contract terms for the supply of goods and services online

  • Easements – Key Issues and Update

  • Employment Status – Employees, Workers and the Self-Employed

  • Endeavour Clauses And What They Mean

  • Essential Planning & Building RegulationsComing soon

  • Estate Rentcharges – Where Are We Now?

  • Executing Documents Using Electronic Signatures

  • Executing documents using electronic signaturesComing soon

  • Exercising Tenant Break Options Effectively

  • Extension of the Disclosure Pilot Scheme

  • Family Law – The Key Case Law Developments of 2020

  • Family Law: Case Law and Statutory Advancements 2021

  • FATCA & CRS – when are they relevant to your trusts?

  • Financial Remedies, Cohabitation and Marital Breakdown 2021

  • Fire Safety In Multi-Storey, Multi-Occupied Residential Buildings

  • Fixtures, Fittings And Chattels – Do You Know The Difference And Why It Matters?

  • Flat Leases – Tips and Traps from Recent Cases

  • Flexible working and indirect discriminationComing soon

  • Fraud and CyberCrime Update 2020

  • GDPR – international transfers, enforcement and proposed changes

  • GDPR and Compensation – Heads of Claim, Types of Loss and Quantum

  • GDPR Update

  • Gifts to children in Wills

  • Guardianship Issues and Wills

  • Guidance in Running Cohabitation Cases – Working through the Maze

  • Health & Welfare LPAs and Advance Decisions

  • Holiday pay: rolled-up pay, commission, overtime and back pay

  • How Much Is The Employment Tribunal Claim Worth?

  • How The Latest Costs Rulings Affect Your Practice

  • How to Maximise Your Recoveries in Litigation

  • ICO Age Appropriate Design Code

  • Identity and the Land Registry

  • Implied terms, good faith and Braganza dutiesComing soon

  • Inheritance (Provision for Family & Dependants) Act 1975 cases 2020-21

  • Injunctions in Family and Children Cases – Core Principles, Developments and Updates 2022

  • Injunctions in Personal Protection Cases – Civil and Criminal Enforcement

  • Introduction to Estate Accounts

  • Introduction to Family Law Practice and Procedure for New Entrants

  • Investment by Trustees

  • Key Principles of No-Fault Divorce and Developments in Online Divorce Procedure

  • Land Joint Ventures

  • Land Registry Practice: recent developments and what’s on the horizon

  • Latest Inheritance (Provision for Family & Dependents) Act 1975 (IPFD 1975) Cases

  • Lease Extension – avoiding the problem areas

  • Leasehold Update

  • Legal Sector Affinity Group (LSAG) Guidance on AML

  • Lies, exaggeration and fundamental dishonesty

  • Listed buildings – issues for conveyancersComing soon

  • Listed Buildings – Key Issues

  • Long residential lease updateComing soon

  • MLCO and MLRO roles explained

  • MLCO/MLRO roles explainedComing soon

  • Modifying Restrictive Covenants

  • Money Laundering – An Introductory Guide for New Entrants and Support Staff

  • Monthly Update on Wills Probate Trusts Tax and Elderly Client December 2020

  • Monthly Update on Wills Probate Trusts Tax and Elderly Client January 2021

  • Monthly Update on Wills Probate Trusts Tax and Elderly Client March 2021

  • Monthly Update on Wills, Probate, Trusts, Tax and Elderly Client Matters – February 2021

  • New Domestic Abuse Legislation 2021 – Essential Update for Practitioners

  • Online Defamation Update

  • Overage and conditional contracts

  • Perpetuities and Accumulations – a refresher

  • Pre-contract enquiries

  • Pre-Nuptial Agreements and Inheritances

  • Preparing to complete an online application for a Grant

  • Privilege and DisclosureComing soon

  • Problems with Evidence 2021

  • Progress in Private Children Law 2021

  • Progress in Public Children Matters 2021

  • Recent Changes in Property Development

  • Recent trust cases and their implications in practice

  • Residential Property Practice Update

  • Residential Property Practice Update – March 2021

  • Residential Property Practice Update December 2021

  • Residential Property Practice Update February 2022Coming soon

  • Residential Property Practice Update June 2021

  • Residential Property Practice Update September 2021

  • Residential Property Winter Update

  • Resilience and psychological wellbeing for lawyers

  • Retail Leases in a Changing World Part 1 – Turnover Rents, New Use Classes Order, Breaking the Lease, Quiet Enjoyment and Derogation from Grant

  • Retail Leases in a Changing World Part 2 – Keep-Open Covenants, Tenant Insolvency and CIGA, Landlord’s Consent and Terminal Dilapidations

  • Roundup of recent Will related developments 2021

  • Running Divorce and other Relationship Breakdown Applications – Essential Practice and Online Procedure

  • Secure Accommodation and Deprivation Cases Involving Children: What do you need to know?

  • Service charges: liability and recoverability – advice for landlords AND tenants

  • Shared Ownership Leases – the very latest developments

  • Solicitors and Client Costs Disputes

  • Spousal By-pass TrustsComing soon

  • SRA Accounts Rules 2019 – A 2021 Update

  • SRA Accounts Rules Update

  • SRA Standards & Regulations – the New Normal (2021 Update)

  • Statutory Wills – review and developments

  • Summary Judgment, Striking Out and Ending Litigation without a Trial

  • Tackling tricky issues in commercial leases Part 1 – tenant break options, service charges and recent cases

  • Tackling tricky issues in commercial leases part 2 – guarantees, rent review and insurance

  • Tax Implications of Separation and Divorce

  • Taxation Requirements Of Complex Estates

  • Ten Tips and Traps When Acting for Developers Buying Land

  • Tenant insolvency: advice for landlordsComing soon

  • Tenants’ Rights of First Refusal under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1987 – Landlord’s PerspectiveComing soon

  • Terminal dilapidations: a practical approach

  • Tests and Tools in Capacity Assessment

  • The changing face of litigation – are you ready?

  • The complexity of RNRB in estate administrationComing soon

  • The New Witness Statement Regime 2021

  • The Tenant’s Perspective on Rights of First Refusal under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1987Coming soon

  • Tips and traps when drafting legal documents Part 1

  • Tips and traps when drafting legal documents Part 2

  • Tips Relating to Trusts Created During Lifetime

  • Topical issues in trust administrationComing soon

  • Trust Registration Service and 5AMLD

  • Understanding Local Authority Processes: Twin Tracking, Fostering and Adoption Procedures

  • Unfair Dismissal – Dealing with Employment Status Constructive Dismissal and Redundancy

  • Unusual Grant Applications

  • Unusual Problems with Land – Finding Solutions

  • Use of Wardship and Inherent Jurisdiction in Children Cases

  • Vires Issues – Avoiding The Pitfalls

  • Wardship and Inherent Jurisdiction in Children Cases – Key Principles and 2022 UpdateComing soon

  • What a trustee should know before agreeing to act

  • Whistleblowing: causation, interim relief, compensation and settlement

  • Will Drafting and the RNRB

  • Will Drafting Tips 2021

  • Winners and losers: Working out who won the case

  • that in of themselves do useful things” but when put together they “do even smarter things”.

    He said: “Kira and Neota are terrific in their own right [but] actually when you think about ideas and combine them, the sum of the parts is even greater than the individual pieces”.

    Mr Waisberg said bricolage meant “clients [are] able to extend systems without even the vendor knowing that’s happening… our clients can dream up ways to use our systems… and build them into something greater than we would ever have thought of doing ourselves”.

    Elsewhere at the conference, an eight-product competitive pitch for the 2017 Legal Geek start-up award was won by AI-enabled contract management platform, Juro. The runner-up was F-LEX, an on-demand legal service for paralegals.

    Jimmy Vestbirk, the founder of Legal Geek, said Juro had had a “spectacular” year. He added that the conference was “just another example of how the legal tech sector continues to disrupt the legal industry, and make improvements to it”.

    He continued: “Today’s event was twice the size of our inaugural [conference] in 2016 and that is all due to our members far and wide who continue to invest their time to meet and network with each other, swap ideas, and drive legal tech forward.”


    Leave a Comment

    By clicking Submit you consent to Legal Futures storing your personal data and confirm you have read our Privacy Policy and section 5 of our Terms & Conditions which deals with user-generated content. All comments will be moderated before posting.

    Required fields are marked *
    Email address will not be published.

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


    Automated justice: striking the balance in injury claims

    No professional sector is immune from automation – even the law. However, the adoption of automated systems to settle routine injury claims raises a number of important ethical questions.

    Conveyancers: are you afraid of outsourcing?

    For many years, outsourcing has been seen as a bit of a scary prospect within the conveyancing sector. But thanks to the stamp duty holiday, conveyancers are now realising some of the many benefits.

    You win some, you lose some – class actions post Google

    In November, Google received two court rulings, through which it both closed and opened the door to class actions against it. So what do the decisions mean for future class actions?

    Loading animation