- Legal Futures - https://www.legalfutures.co.uk -

Divided reaction to MPs’ support for client account interest scheme

Dixon: ILCA proposal is flawed

MPs’ support for an Interest on Lawyers’ Client Account (ILCA) scheme has opened up a divide between the legal and advice sectors.

But there was broader support for the idea of a national legal service akin the NHS 111.

In its report on access to legal services [1], the justice select committee identified an ILCA scheme as one way to provide substantial additional funding to support access to justice.

But the committee did not like the Ministry of Justice’s proposed scheme, which would see interest simply funnelled into its general budget.

Rather, as in other jurisdictions, it should be administered independently of government and operate on the basis of transparent grant-making criteria focused on reducing unmet legal need, it said.

It should maintain reserves to manage volatility, and include safeguards such as appropriate exemptions for legal aid providers and other financially vulnerable firms.

Law Society president Brett Dixon said the solicitors’ body agreed with the committee’s concerns about the government’s proposal.

He went on: “But we doubt that a workable scheme can be devised that satisfactorily addresses those concerns.

“The scheme cannot and should not proceed. The proposal is flawed, sets a damaging precedent and conflicts with wider government commitments on growth.

“It is unlikely to generate more than a tiny fraction of the sums needed to meaningfully improve the justice system, and it is unlikely to be a significant or reliable new source of revenue. It is simply not fit for purpose.”

However, AdviceUK, which represents more than 700 independent advice services, and the Law Centres Network (LCN) both issued statements supporting the ILCA scheme as outlined by the committee.

The LCN stressed that new funding like this “must be ring-fenced for unmet legal need and additional to legal aid, as the committee recommends”.

CILEX president Sara Fowler said: “While the suggested sources of additional funding have the potential to be of some assistance, they are not reliable and do not fix the fundamental issues around legal aid and the court and tribunal backlogs.”

More broadly, there was backing for the idea of a national legal service, as championed by the committee.

LCN director Julie Bishop said: “This report draws deeply on what law centres see every day, and it points the right way: national leadership, delivered locally, with legal assistance treated as the prevention it is.

“A national legal service can build on the law centres already rooted in their communities. What it needs now is enough lawyers to take on the cases it identifies, and the long-term investment to sustain them.”

Mr Dixon said a national legal service would be “a helpful addition to signposting people to legal advice but is not a substitute for a sustainably funded network of local legal providers”.

Liz Bayram, chief executive of AdviceUK, said better signposting was only part of the answer. “There must be properly funded, independent advice services for people to turn to, wherever they live.

“We know the public support this: a national poll commissioned by AdviceUK showed that 85% of the UK public agree that free, independent advice should be treated as an essential local service.

“Advice is the front door of prevention. The government now needs to act on the justice committee’s recommendations and work with the advice sector to build a system that puts early advice within everyone’s reach.”

Legal support charity Advicenow said any new co-ordinated service must be devolved, locally responsive, with the full spectrum of education, digital, in-person and specialist help, as well as supporting trusted community workers on the ground.

Chair Fiona Edwards said: “We would welcome having national standards and a national focus equivalent to that of the NHS – however delivery and coordination has to be as local as possible.”

The charity also called for an urgent, nationally recognised mark for legal information so both the public and AI platforms could distinguish reliable legal guidance from inaccurate, unreliable or AI generated content.

CEO Dr Lisa Wintersteiger added: “We cannot underestimate the impact of AI at a time when trust in institutions is already waning. When people cannot access legal help, they turn to AI.

“Inaccurate or misleading advice about the law wastes people’s time and money, clogs up courts and tribunals with avoidable backlogs, and further erodes faith in the systems meant to defend their interests.”