
Cowper-Coles: Very aggressive litigation conduct from claimant lawyers
Solicitors should not be able to launch libel litigation without investigating the truth of the cases made by their clients, MPs on the justice select committee have been told.
Rupert Cowper-Coles, partner and head of media at City law firm RPC, also said that the Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) had got a “bloody nose” from its attempts to take action over SLAPPs (strategic lawsuit against public participation).
Addressing a one-off evidence session on whether the law is being used to silence victims and survivors, Mr Cowper-Coles, head of a defence libel practice, said that solicitors currently had “no obligation to warrant” their clients’ instructions.
“If your wealthy client comes up to you and says ‘I didn’t rape her’, you don’t need to say ‘can I see your phone messages?’ or ‘can I see your diary?’. You can just write the letter.
“The Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal has said that acting in your client’s best interests can mean very aggressive litigation conduct.”
Referring to failed high-profile prosecutions before the tribunal, Mr Cowper-Coles went on: “The SRA has quite frankly got a bloody nose from the way it has tried to respond to SLAPPs. Without reform, solicitors are part of the problem.
“I think as a minimum, before you embark on litigation, there should be some sort of due diligence – looking into your client’s case and the truth of it.”
In one of those cases, involving Carter-Ruck partner Claire Gill, the tribunal said [1] doubts about a client’s truthfulness was not a good reason for solicitors to stop acting.
Mr Cowper-Coles said that before he pleaded a truth defence, he had to find sufficient evidence to do so – or at least have it by the time of the trial.
“Libel has a presumption of falsity. Whenever anyone accuses someone of sexual violence, English law tells them it’s not true and they’re lying unless they can prove it’s true. The more serious the allegation, the stronger the evidence that is expected.
“At the moment, it’s slightly depressing but all the regulatory activity in this area has given clarity to claimant lawyers that they can vigorously pursue their clients’ interests, even when they suspect their clients are lying to them – unless the client is lying to them.
“If you want to pursue libel litigation through the courts, there should some obligation on the solicitor to ensure that the instructions they are receiving are accurate.”
Answering a question from Labour MP and committee chair Catherine Atkinson, Mr Cowper-Coles said the SRA had “got nowhere” with enforcing the solicitor’s duties to the court and not to take unfair advantage and had “ended up with a very large costs bill”.
Jennifer Robinson, barrister at Doughty Street Chambers and a specialist in media and human rights law, said restrictions on non-disclosure agreements (NDAs) contained in the Employment Rights Act 2025 were “forward-looking” and did not cover historic NDAs.
Where somebody had not kept a copy of an historic NDA which was still binding on them, and where the other side’s solicitors refused to release one, the only way to obtain it was by making an application to the High Court, which could cost “thousands of pounds or more, she said.
“I don’t think that anyone has looked at that from a policy point of view and it needs to be looked at.” She described the situation as “absolutely Kafkaesque”.
Ms Robinson said it could be “incredibly expensive” for women to prove allegations of sexual offences were true in court.“ How can we tackle violence against women if we can’t talk about it?”
Survivors could experience being sued by their perpetrators as a “form of abuse” and there should “legislative safeguards” to stop it.
She added that NDAs were still being widely used and were “a massive problem”.
Harriet Wistrich, a solicitor and CEO of the Centre for Women’s Justice, said defamation proceedings required “very experienced lawyers” and reforms were needed so people were not reliant on pro bono help.
She suggested that either a ‘no costs’ procedure could be introduced or the question of whether there was a public interest in the allegations could be determined “right at the beginning” of proceedings.