Barrister under fire for “racist” comments about Royal baby


Toch: Very sorry

A family law barrister has been suspended from the innovative business she founded after being accused of making racist comments about the new Royal baby.

In a statement posted on Twitter yesterday, the board of the Family Law Café said it has suspended Joanna Toch “with immediate effect pending an internal review into her recent comments on Twitter”.

It continued: “FLC considers her comments as offensive, unacceptable and highly contradictory to the inclusive manner in which FLC has always and will continue to work with members of all communities in managing the challenges of matrimonial and family disputes.”

Ms Toch responded to a tweet from controversial writer Julie Burchill, who described the name of the Duke and Duchess of Sussex’s new baby, Lilibet Diana, as “a missed opportunity”. Referring to George Floyd, she said: “They could’ve called it Georgina Floydina!”

Ms Toch replied: “No Doria? Don’t black names matter?” Doria Ragland is Meghan Markle’s mother.

Ms Burchill answered that she “was hoping for Doria Oprah, the racist rotters”, to which Ms Toch responded: “Doprah?”

The exchange sparked heavy criticism on social media, with several sharing the procedure to complain to the Bar Standards Board.

Ms Toch wrote later on Twitter: “I am very sorry for the comment and what I saw as a joke. I’ve fought during my professional life against racism which is abhorrent. I’m not a judge [some Twitter users had said she was] and I have children of colour and I apologise unreservedly.”

In a later tweet, she added: “It was a joke and I’m sorry if I upset you.”

Her Twitter account has now been deleted, as has Ms Burchill’s.

The Family Law Bar Association tweeted today: “Comments on Twitter about the Sussex’s newborn baby have been brought to our attention. As one of the individuals is a member of the Family Bar we have written to the individual and are referring the exchanges to the BSB, the Bar Council and other relevant bodies.

“We make it clear that FLBA condemns the comments by the individual which are completely inappropriate and have no place in our society. Racism of any kind cannot be tolerated and cannot be justified as a ‘joke’.”

The Family Law Café was set up by Ms Toch with solicitor turned corporate financier Peter Tahany, who are listed at Companies House as the only two directors. It went live in 2017.

Users are initially contacted by a ‘host’ for a free initial consultation. They are then directed to an ‘expeditor’ – an experienced family law barrister or solicitor – who maps out the best way to take the case forward.




    Readers Comments

  • Georglyn Joseph Williams says:

    The comments were NO joke. She had these thoughts for a long time and just put these thoughts on her Twitter page.
    There is NO excuse or place for RACISM

  • Nicholas Buckworth says:

    In what twisted universe is the “Doprah” comment racist?

  • Estelle Michael says:

    They just can’t help themselves. Only the good Lord knows how she’s handled legal matters for ethnic minorities. Sad that people walk around with so much hate.

  • Chris says:

    Completely ridiculous twitter storm. Can we agree a working definition of racism as ‘denigration of persons of another race’? If so, there was none here.


Leave a Comment

By clicking Submit you consent to Legal Futures storing your personal data and confirm you have read our Privacy Policy and section 5 of our Terms & Conditions which deals with user-generated content. All comments will be moderated before posting.

Required fields are marked *
Email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Blog


Automated justice: striking the balance in injury claims

No professional sector is immune from automation – even the law. However, the adoption of automated systems to settle routine injury claims raises a number of important ethical questions.


Conveyancers: are you afraid of outsourcing?

For many years, outsourcing has been seen as a bit of a scary prospect within the conveyancing sector. But thanks to the stamp duty holiday, conveyancers are now realising some of the many benefits.


You win some, you lose some – class actions post Google

In November, Google received two court rulings, through which it both closed and opened the door to class actions against it. So what do the decisions mean for future class actions?


Loading animation