3,000 law firms “could be forced to close or merge”


Williams: Firms need to take tough decisions

As many as 3,000 law firms could be forced to close or merge over the next few years after the conveyancing bubble bursts and the recession really kicks in, a leading law firm consultant has warned.

Viv Williams said many firms had used Covid loans to pay for this year’s indemnity insurance and were “riding it out, hoping things will improve”.

However, he said the conveyancing “bubble” would burst when the stamp duty holiday ended next year, and the government Covid loans would have to be paid back in the second quarter.

“Family and conveyancing have gone well but company and commercial have collapsed, along with commercial property.”

Mr Williams, who founded Viv Williams Consulting this summer, said the whiplash reforms in April next year would add to the challenges facing law firms, along with the prospect of another big hike in indemnity insurance premiums.

“I think about 3,000 law firms will not survive the next few years [there are currently some 10,000 in all]. They will either close or merge.

“They should be thinking strategically and taking tough decisions. Most of them have done OK by furloughing staff, closing offices and taking rent reviews, but where do they go from here?”

Mr Williams said a survey of 210 law firm clients of his consultancy found that more than 60% had furloughed staff since the pandemic began, and half of those firms did not expect to re-employ their full complement.

Almost half (45%) had permanently laid off back-office personnel, while three-quarters had cut or terminated their marketing spend.

A further 45% of firms were looking at options to restructure or redevelop their business, while 35% were considering closing or disposing of their firm. Only 20% thought their law firm would remain unchanged by the pandemic.

Mr Williams said the firms involved in the survey had an average turnover of £2m to £5m, with only one having a turnover of over £20m. Three-quarters handled conveyancing work.

He said his consultants were noticing that billings were suffering because fee-earners had lost much of their back-office support and managing cash flow had become “a major preoccupation”.

The survey found that compliance was becoming more difficult because so many staff were working remotely or furloughed and internal communications problems had grown as managers found themselves “overwhelmed by the tactical issues” associated with keeping the business functioning normally.

Business development and long-term strategic objectives were being lost as resources were entirely taken up by day-to-day tactical management.

Mr Williams said law firms involved in conveyancing had seen increases of 30% to 50% in their indemnity insurance premiums this year, a big change from the “soft” insurance market which had existed for the past 20 years.

He said firms should consider transferring their back-office functions into a separate business to reduce their turnover for indemnity insurance.

Mr Williams said everyone in the world of law firm merger advisers had more buyers than sellers. He expected to complete eight mergers in a normal year, but this year had only completed two.

“Law firms are busy because conveyancing is flat out and they’ve got cash in the bank. Lawyers with cash in the bank don’t take decisions.

“I’ve had loads of meetings, but nobody is taking any action. Hopefully in the New Year more firms will make a decision on what they want to do.”




    Readers Comments

  • ANTHONY HUGHES says:

    Sadly I agree with this, but we have to ask if it is natural market forces being accelerated by C-19 as well as a hardening of the PII market. Law remains largely a cottage industry with over 10,000 firms around the country. Consolidation is overdue and has been resisted by many who simply want to remain as their own master when it is not necessarily sustainable. The other big issue is that so many firms have a poor risk profile and or PII history and they simply cannot expect the continue in those circumstances. The flip side is of course that good boutique businesses will always be able to find a home in merger terms!


Leave a Comment

By clicking Submit you consent to Legal Futures storing your personal data and confirm you have read our Privacy Policy and section 5 of our Terms & Conditions which deals with user-generated content. All comments will be moderated before posting.

Required fields are marked *
Email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Blog


“How much does your building weigh, Norman?”

Mentoring programmes are increasingly common in law firms. The weight of academic literature points to the positive benefits of mentoring on professional development.


Cognitive diversity – why it should be top of your list in 2021

Whilst many firms have made admirable leaps to improve diversity, both at board level and more broadly, one area of diversity that is less well-known or reported on is that of cognitive diversity.


Loading animation