Guest post by Jacob Poole, housing operations coordinator at Manchester firm Pabla & Pabla

Poole: Where is the data?
Social housing landlords are outraged by the ongoing increase in housing disrepair claims. This is no surprise, considering our research showed claims brought against local councils increased by 392% from 2020 and 2024, with no indication they will let up.
Now the Ministry of Justice (MoJ) is investigating these claims. Its consultation, from December 2025, was heavily contributed to by the main regulators of the legal sector, the Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) and the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA).
The consultation referenced the SRA’s work on high-volume consumer claims and cited “concerns about some solicitors not fulfilling their obligations to always act in their clients’ best interests and follow all the rules and regulations.”
But are housing disrepair claims really being made at high volume? And are solicitors failing to represent tenants to bring homes back into repair?
Is there a housing disrepair problem?
The MoJ’s consultation starts off on a sombre note: 10% of social housing and 21% of private rented housing respectively do not meet the Decent Homes Standard (DHS).
The new DHS will apply from 2035 and the Regulatory Policy Committee stated that, if it applied now, 45% of social housing and 48% of private rented housing would fail the standard.
Further, in the last decade, legislation like Awaab’s Law, the Homes (Fitness for Human Habitation) Act 2018 and the Renters’ Rights Act 2025 have been introduced to improve tenant rights. It should be no surprise that more solicitors are getting involved in claims.
However, this increased presence from claimant firms has been accompanied by concerns over solicitor and claims management company (CMC) behaviour. Lobbied by social housing landlords, the MoJ’s consultation was produced in close collaboration with the regulators, the SRA and the FCA.
The document explains concerns about CMCs and solicitor firms that are failing to provide prospective clients proper information about claims, as well as using aggressive sign-up tactics like door knocking and cold calling.
The SRA’s principal concerns seem to be that claims are being brought en masse. The housing disrepair problem seems to be defined by a notion that solicitors are taking on more than they can sufficiently manage.
What is a high-volume consumer claim?
According to the SRA’s guidance, a high-volume consumer claim is defined as a claim that “arises when large numbers of consumers file claims against the same organisation, or in relation to the same issue”.
It is concerned about how solicitor and CMC behaviour is affected by these concentrated claims. This includes worries about “how clients are onboarded, a lack of transparency around fees, costs, and how firms manage claims day-to-day, and how funding for claims works”.
At the time of writing, the SRA has 109 open investigations relating to 76 firms that manage these claims, which total in the millions.
Consumer claims that are wilfully mismanaged are extremely concerning. It is no doubt the responsibility of the SRA as the regulator not only to sanction bad actors in the industry, but also to highlight where the main problems lie.
Are housing disrepair claims high volume?
The increase in claims can be attributed to a lot of different factors. As fixed costs were introduced into personal injury claims in 2021, many private solicitors decided to retrain into new markets.
Disrepair claims are also mostly brought against social housing landlords, due to the consistency in recovering costs and the security in longer term tenancies.
It could very well be argued that they do not match the description of high volume. They are complicated and can sometimes take years to settle or reach trial, with multiple expert reports and client vulnerabilities to consider. Also, these claims are brought against a variety of different landlords, who all have different tactics for their defence.
They can be extremely stressful experiences for clients, who are living day-to-day in often awful conditions. If the housing stock wasn’t in such a dire state, then tenants wouldn’t be looking to bring claims at all.
The housing disrepair data gap
The SRA has suggested that housing disrepair claims are being brought en masse with no consideration of the client or their needs. If this is the case, surely there must be data to support which firms are bringing such claims?
How many reports of bad practice have there been against firms bringing disrepair claims? How many open investigations are there into firms doing this? Does the regulator even consider itself to be the relevant body to oversee these claims?
Besides, are housing disrepair claims being brought in much greater volume than, say, clinical negligence? The SRA does not deem them to be high volume, so it makes little sense that housing disrepair claims are branded in this way.
The MoJ consultation suggested restricting housing disrepair claims, such as by introducing fixed costs and banning referral fees. Although bad practice must be ironed out of the sector, it seems disingenuous to propose such changes without presenting any data to quantify the full extent of the problem.
The SRA was contacted for further comment.










Leave a Comment