How SCIL aims to make the clinical negligence system fair

ARAGPosted by Mike Knight, UK sales manager at Litigation Futures Associate ARAG

The Society of Clinical Injury Lawyers (SCIL) represent many of the most experienced and dedicated, specialist clinical injury lawyers and law firms in the country.

Its members have looked carefully at the government’s proposals with regard to fixed recoverable costs (FRC) in cases valued up to £25,000. These proposals have come about due to government and liability insurer concern over the costs incurred by patients of the NHS and other medical providers who have suffered injury from preventable clinical negligence.

SCIL has rightly pointed out that clinical negligence claims at this level cannot be handled like road traffic or similar personal injury claims, and are complex, often involving multiple medical experts in various fields.

Further, they are emotionally sensitive for the innocent victims, who sought assistance from the medical provider, but instead suffered preventable injury. Finally, costs cannot be fixed unless the claims process has been fixed first.

SCIL has put forward proposals to both address these issues and reduce the costs payable by the negligent defendants. These:

  • confirm the NHS’s advertised duty of candour has not worked as well as hoped;
  • make clear that medical providers must learn from their mistakes to reduce similar, preventable, negligent actions injuring future patients;
  • suggest a process whereby specialist ‘safety champions’ are appointed in each NHS trust with the authority to ensure this learning process makes swift, permanent patient safety changes to medical practice, when a preventable error is identified;
  • suggest a fair, clear, staged and timed legal process for notifying and making claims, once an error has occurred and a patient has been injured; and
  • confirm that such a claims process will encourage compliance by having suitable sanctions built in, to punish any party not complying with its requirements.

SCIL believes its scheme will ultimately not only reduce the costs of the claims process but will also lower costs by reducing the number of clinical errors which lead to claims in the first place.

It is supported by the respected patient protection charity, the Action against Medical Accidents.

However, injured patients will still need legal expenses protection in order to bring a claim.

ARAG continues to support innocent victims in pursuing their legal rights and is pleased to work with SCIL members and will continue to provide after-the-event insurance to injured patients to support the investigation of potential claims and protect unsuccessful claimants from adverse costs in certain circumstances where qualified one-way costs shifting does not apply, such as not beating a defendant’s part 36 offer.

Associate News is provided by Legal Futures Associates.
Find out about becoming an Associate


Loading animation