Suspended sentence for solicitor who defrauded HMRC

Print This Post

13 September 2016


Tax returns: false claims

Tax returns: false claims

A solicitor who fraudulently claimed £37,000 in income tax repayments has been handed a suspended prison sentence and told she was “wholly unsuitable to be a solicitor”.

Dianna Gerald, also known as Dianna Lee, who is 49 and from Worcester, was a family law solicitor and company director of Family Law Consultants Limited, trading as Simply Solicitors in Cheltenham and Worcester.

She was found to have falsified information on her 2009 and 2010 income tax returns to over-claim tax repayments. She did this by inflating expenses, including staff costs and refunds relating to clients’ divorce fees, and fabricated invoices, letters and an employment contract to support the claims.

HM Revenue & Customs compliance officers discovered that the figures shown on her business records did not match those declared on her tax returns.

She was found guilty of four counts of fraud by false representation on 7 July 2016 after a 12-day trial at Manchester Crown Court, and sentenced last week to 21 months in prison, suspended for 18 months, and 200 hours unpaid work. She was also given an 18-month supervision order and ordered to pay costs of £10,000.

Handing down the sentence, His Honour Judge Steiger QC said: “She had gone to great lengths to defraud the Revenue – including the generation of bogus documents – and in doing so had attacked the character and reputation of her fellow partners and employees. In my judgment her behaviour was disgraceful and she is wholly unsuitable to be a solicitor”

Stuart Taylor, assistant director of HMRC’s fraud investigation service said: “Dianna Gerald abused her position of trust as a solicitor to defraud the taxpaying public. Tax fraud is not tolerated by HMRC, and we will take action regardless of the resources of those committing the fraud, to ensure that no one is beyond our reach.”

A spokesman for the Solicitors Regulation Authority said it was aware of the decision and was “currently looking into the case to consider our next steps”.



One Response to “Suspended sentence for solicitor who defrauded HMRC”

  1. I’d like to know how many people suffered loss as a result of this person’s incompetence and is it likely that there is any mechanism for recompense ?

  2. P Mellersh on December 22nd, 2016 at 9:26 pm

Leave a comment

* Denotes required field

All comments will be moderated before posting. Please see our Terms and Conditions

Legal Futures Blog

Algorithms and the law

Jeremy Barnett

Our aim is to start a discussion in the legal profession on the legal impact of algorithms on firms, software developers, insurers, and lawyers. In a longer paper, we consider whether algorithms should have a legal personality, an issue which will likely provoke an intense debate between those who believe in regulation and those who believe that ‘code is law’. In law, companies have the rights and obligations of a person. Algorithms are rapidly emerging as artificial persons: a legal entity that is not a human being but for certain purposes is legally considered to be a natural person. Intelligent algorithms will increasingly require formal training, testing, verification, certification, regulation, insurance, and status in law.

August 22nd, 2017