Big CMCs face £40,000 hit as government names day for new complaints regime

Print This Post

4 November 2014


Government: cross-subsidy needed

The Legal Ombudsman (LeO) is set to start receiving complaints about claims management complaints (CMCs) from 28 January 2015 – some two and a half years after the switch from the Claims Management Regulator was first mooted by the government.

The move will mean that CMCs could have to pay consumers compensation, which the current regime does not provide for.

The go-ahead came yesterday after the Ministry of Justice published its response to the consultation on how CMCs will be charged to fund the 3,000 cases a year that LeO expects to receive, at a total cost, including the expenses involved in setting up the new service, of around £3.2m a year.

Despite some opposition, it is pressing ahead with a sliding scale of fees based on annual turnover. The biggest CMCs will pay an amount equal to 0.33% of their annual turnover up to £1m, plus 0.22% of turnover between £1m and £5m, plus 0.18% above £5m. This will all be subject to a cap of £40,000.

Error, group does not exist! Check your syntax! (ID: 14)

At the other end of the scale, CMCs with turnovers of between £75,000 and £163,636 will pay £540, falling to £340 for those with turnovers of between £25,000 and £75,000. The minimum fee will be £75.

Most objections were based on the grounds that larger firms will pay higher fees to subsidise lower fees for smaller firms, which may have poorer customer services and complaints records.

The Ministry of Justice said the consultation made it clear that there would be a cross-subsidy, but that it was justified “as the government is committed to recovering the whole of the Legal Ombudsman’s claims management costs (less the Legal Ombudsman’s case fee income) from the regulated claims management industry, and other ways of structuring the fees would put a disproportionate burden on smaller claims management companies.

“No novel arguments were put forward during the consultation to change our belief that the approach is justified in these circumstances.”

However, there was a commitment to keep the fee framework under the review and, “dependent on the trends in claims management complaints… we will consider whether the structure should be altered to incorporate a greater ‘polluter pays’ element in the future”.

There will be no commensurate reduction in the costs of running the Claims Management Regulator, however, as resource will be refocused on enforcement work.

The ministry yesterday issued another consultation on the technical changes it needs to make to CMCs’ regulatory regime to incorporate the change and bring the requirements on CMCs in line with those on others subject to LeO’s jurisdiction.

LeO’s head of claims management, Simon Tunnicliffe, said: “This is an important step forward for the ombudsman. We look forward to playing our part in raising standards across the claims management industry, and to finally giving consumers access to redress where they have received poor service.”

Tags: , ,



Leave a comment

* Denotes required field

All comments will be moderated before posting. Please see our Terms and Conditions

Legal Futures Blog

Lawyers must now draw on the data and drive change

Chris Marston 2014

The results from this year’s legal services consumer tracker survey make for interesting reading. In its sixth year, the research finds that a firm’s reputation continues to grow in importance, holding its top slot as the number one factor influencing choice of lawyer, with price remaining a strong second, reflected in a shift towards higher numbers of fixed-fee transactions. Alongside, it reports that trust in lawyers has declined to 42%, from 47% in 2012. It’s useful information as far as it goes, but what is the sector going to do with it?

September 26th, 2016